GUIDE

Hotel, Simple Lodging, Minpaku or Rental: Comparing Them as Investments

The same building can be operated as a hotel or simple lodging, as a minpaku, or rented out. Operating days, procedures, workload and the treatment on sale all change. This guide sets out the axes for comparing them as investments.

In short

Compared with rental housing, lodging is an investment whose income moves with occupancy and rate, with more operational work and more legal checks. Hotels and simple lodging run under a Hotel Business Act license have no cap on days and can be taken over. Minpaku is capped at 180 days a year and the notification does not transfer to a buyer.

The short answer: compare on days, zoning, operations and exit

Hotel / ryokanSimple lodgingMinpakuRental housing
ProcedureHotel Business Act licenseHotel Business Act licenseNotificationNone
Operating daysNo capNo capUp to 180 days a year (ordinances may shorten this)—
Where it can operateZoning districts where hotels can be builtSameCan be notified even in exclusive residential districts (subject to ordinances)Most zoning districts
Building classificationHotel / ryokanHotel / ryokanResidenceResidence
How income is setRoom rate × occupancyRoom rate × occupancyRoom rate × nights stayed (capped)Monthly rent
Operational workloadHighHighHigh (often entrusted to a management company)Low
On saleWith approval of the business transfer, the operation can be taken overSameThe notification does not transferCan be sold with tenants in place

Days set the ceiling on revenue

Minpaku is capped by law at 180 days a year, and ward ordinances shorten this in some areas. Facilities run under a Hotel Business Act license have no cap. The revenue ceiling is set by the days you can operate. → Operating days and areas

Zoning decides which systems are available

Hotel Business Act facilities cannot, in principle, be built in exclusive residential districts. Minpaku can be notified there, but more wards restrict it by ordinance. → Minpaku vs. simple lodging

Operations: cost and workload

Lodging generates daily work: reservations, guest communication, cleaning, maintenance and legally required records. Because operating costs take a large share, comparing gross yield with rental housing does not tell you much. Look at what remains after operating costs and loan repayments.

Exit

  • A Hotel Business Act business can be taken over by the buyer with approval of the business transfer → Can a hotel license be transferred?
  • A minpaku notification does not transfer. In areas closed to new minpaku, the buyer cannot continue → Buying an operating minpaku
  • Rental housing can be sold with tenants in place

Ordinance changes can move the premise

In Tokyo's 23 wards, amendments that cut minpaku days or refuse new minpaku continue, and amendments requiring a front desk or on-site staff for Hotel Business Act facilities are also advancing. The days and operating model your investment assumed can change. → What changes in 2027

A sensible order of thinking

  1. Check which systems are available from the zoning district and the ward ordinance
  2. Set the operating days and look at the revenue ceiling
  3. Decide whether to operate yourself or entrust it, and set operating costs
  4. Compare with the rent you would get as rental housing
  5. Check the treatment on sale and the fallback use if ordinances change

How we can help

Kreis Networks is a licensed real estate broker and a registered residential lodging management business. We introduce lodging and income properties, and use our in-house AI and data analysis to help assess area demand and earning potential. A simple income estimate is provided as part of the consultation. Contact us in English through our contact form.

This page is a translation of our Japanese page. If there is any difference, the Japanese version prevails. Japanese version

Sources (in Japanese)

  1. e-Gov法令検索「旅館業法」
  2. e-Gov法令検索「住宅宿泊事業法」
  3. 観光庁 民泊制度総合サイト「住宅宿泊事業とは」
  4. 東京都都市整備局「用途地域による建築物の用途制限の概要」
  5. 観光庁・厚生労働省・国土交通省「住宅宿泊事業法に規定する届出住宅に係るゼロ日規制等について(技術的助言)」(2026年7月15日)

Thinking about minpaku in Tokyo?

From checking whether a property can operate to day-to-day management. We reply in English or Japanese. Consultation is free.